Gary Smith EDA Consulting in Electronic Design

Gary Smith EDA (GSEDA) is the leading provider of market intelligence and advisory services for the global Electronic Design Automation (EDA), Electronic System Level (ESL) design, and related technology markets.

    Mentor and Flowmaster - Thinking Out of the Box

    Mentor and Flowmaster - Thinking Out of the Box

    Mentor Graphics has announced that it has acquired the Flowmaster Group, a UK-based provider of computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulation software. Flowmaster’s core product is a one-dimensional CFD solution (versus the more well-known 3D CFD approach) that allow for more rapid modeling of fluid and thermal flows in systems upfront in the design.

    This isn’t the first time Mentor has reached into the mechanical world. In 2008, Mentor acquired Flomerics, a provider of 3D CFD software focused primarily on thermal analysis. Unlike most of its main competitors, Mentor has a complete arm dedicated to mechanical analysis that goes beyond wire harness and cabling. Mentor sees the Flowmaster acquisition as broadening its set of solutions for the mechanical space and going deeper into industry verticals.

    It’s not quite clear to us just how the Flowmaster products will be positioned or integrated with the Mentor’s existing mechanical offerings, nor how this acquisition, along with the Flomerics products, might change who Mentor is actually selling to (mechanical engineers, analysts, dedicated CFD groups, corporate CAE). What would be really interesting is to see just how high up the ladder purchasing decisions for historically mechanical-based solutions -- from an EDA vendor -- will be made. Our guess is that currently, CFD decisions are typically made by the actual user, in this case, the CFD group within a company. But, with Mentor being able to offer solutions that delve more deeply into any one industry vertical, will some of these companies begin to see just how the EDA and mechanical worlds might fit together? It will also be interesting to see how Mentor, with stronger marketing power and deeper pockets, might be able to bring the benefits of CFD -- like faster time to market-- into the forefront.

    Nevertheless, Mentor is clearly thinking out of the box here. We’ve been waiting for the EDA and mechanical worlds to come together, or at least near each other. The mechanical vendors have been trying to bridge this gap for years, but so far, it hasn’t been wildly successful. Initial attempts by the mechanical vendors to penetrate the EDA market with PDM tools failed because PDM didn’t accommodate the data management and design flows of EDA. We were hoping that Ansys might be able to bring both worlds closer together with its suite of analysis solutions, but Ansys doesn’t have the same marketing and financial reach that Mentor has. We hope that Mentor is looking into the future where the EDA and mechanical worlds overlap; and we welcome Mentor to take on this challenge.

    To view entire paper, download the PDF here


    • Carmen said on Feb 27th, 2012 10:47:03 AM
      Rick, nice writeup. I strongly suspect that Mentor wants to take Flowmaster's 1D flow analysis and apply it to electronic design methods which use a near-identical 1D solution method for analyzing electronic currents. From an analysis perspective, pressure in hydraulics is directly analogous to voltage in electronics, flow rate can be substituted with current, and hydraulic losses can be substituted with electrical resistance.

      Having said that, most engineers don't refer to 1D flow analysis as "CFD". That's marketing hype, and 1D flow analysis is "low end" technology compared to 3D CFD which is infinitely more sophisticated. 1D is useful only where there is emperical data typically piping networks and proven electronic circuit design applications.

      Does anyone know how much Mentor paid for Flowmaster? As a public company, aren't they obligated to disclose what they paid along with Flowmaster financials?
    • Carmen said on Mar 1st, 2012 08:47:40 AM
      Apologies for referring to the author of this article (Sharon or Gary?) as "Rick" in my previous post. In their conference call a couple of days ago, Mentor finally gave some details about the Flowmaster acquisition, announcing that they paid "about" $15 million for Flowmaster which had annual revenues of "about" $10 million. No other specific financial details were given regarding the Flowmaster acquisition. Well, I guess that's better than nothing.

      It still amazes me how public companies like Mentor spending investors' money can make significant acquisitions without releasing financial details. This deal, on the surface, looks like a good one for Mentor, although we only have sketchy info. Mentor will likely utilize Flowmaster's 1D flow analysis for circuit design analysis applications and take advantage of linking Flowmaster's 1D results to their 3D CFD Flomerics software to leverage additional sales. It surprises me that a market leader like Flowmaster could be bought for only 1.5X annual sales.
    • seo software of [email protected] said on Sep 26th, 2012 09:21:07 AM
      Helpful info. Lucky me I discovered your web site by chance, and I'm stunned why this coincidence did not took place earlier! I bookmarked it.
      seo software
join mailing list join joke list Lori Kate on Twitter
upcoming events
  • Designers Seat Count

    Design Engineering seats by CAE, IC & PCB layout; ESL, Semi and PCB/ FPGA pyramid seats
    Publish date: Oct 2012
  • 2012 Market Trends v2

    RTL and PCB market share, forecast & analysis by sub-apps
    Publish date: Oct 2012
  • 2012 Market Trends v1

    ESL and IC CAD market share, forecast & analysis by sub-apps
    Publish date: Oct 2012